CAPTAIN KIRK STAR TREK

it’s impossible to be objective wie man selecting your favorite Star Trek captain. It calls for making a call wrapped up in sentiment und timing. I beg your pardon captain walk you zuerst encounter? i m sorry one ideal reflected rückseitig to freundin the person you wanted zu be? that easier to try to attempt a clear-eyed consideration des which one would certainly be ns best boss. Sure, there room captains sure kommen sie take freundin on grausam adventures, yet would sie enjoy the ride if your life depended on their decision-making? On the flip side, there are captains that might get the job done without really motivating that much enthusiasm, die Starfleet equivalent von a decent ceo who clearly spends the back half des every change with bei eye on ns clock.

Du schaust: Captain kirk star trek

It’s a worthwhile assumed exercise, and one at the heart of the many recent Star Trek TV series, Star Trek: Discovery, i beg your pardon focuses notfall on a captain but michael Burnham (Sonequa Martin-Green), a scientific research officer struggling kommen sie work her way rückseitig from a snap judgment that finished with her in disgrace. Burnham has deshalb far offered under several captains, und the series has depicted ns effect this has had actually on both her und the officers around her. (And, thus, has much more entries listed below than any other version des Trek.) us considered ns captains featured in various film und TV branches des the Star Trek universe and tried kommen sie rank them based on who would provide the best arbeit experience — und who would be many likely to bring you rückseitig home in one piece.

11. Captain Philippa Georgiou, mirror Universe (Michelle Yeoh)

viewed in: Star Trek: Discovery


*

Managerial style: Imperious und unforgiving, though the description ist complicated von the fact that being imperious and unforgiving is baked into herstellung main mirror universe arbeit as emperor von the Terran Empire. (Or, much more accurately, herstellung job as imperial Majesty, Mother of the Fatherland, Overlord des Vulcan, Dominos of Qo’noS, Regina Andor, Philippa Goergiou Augustus Iaponius Centarius.) There, she battled for and won the top spot an a kill-or-be-killed system in which can makes right, and deception and backstabbing are the norm; to that end, she expects those working under her to understand die rules of the game. Bei other words, she’s awful. But, on die other hand, she yes, really seems to enjoy being awful, notfall to mention ns fringe benefits des having clawed produziert way to the top (fine food, geschlechter slaves, etc.). Those who kann sein get on herstellung murderous wavelength might also have a great time — weil das as lang as that lasts.

Key job moment: When the always adaptive Emperor Georgiou made her way indigenous the spiegel universe to ns prime Star Trek cosmos she used ns opportunity kommen sie save ns day after acquiring thrown into a battle betwee the Federation and the Klingons. However this wasn’t a an easy heel-face turn; as always, it was more a matte of calculation than altruism. Die move won herstellung freedom indigenous those that knew produziert true origins and earned her a spot an the Federation’s super-secretive deep-state procedure Section 31. What might possibly walk wrong?

Would she it is in a good boss? Put simply, working zum this Philippa Georgiou, punkt least in the mirror universe the made her, would median constantly fearing zum your life as part of a pitiless, fascist company hell-bent on conquering ns universe with little regard zum its employees’ quality of life. (Actually, when it’s every spelled out favor that, it sounds favor a nice easy transition from that company America.)

10. Captain Gabriel Lorca (Jason Isaacs)

viewed in: Star Trek: Discovery


*

Managerial style: In a word, cryptic. ~ she’s accepted aboard the Discovery following her mutinous rotate against produziert mentor Captain Georgiou (the früh universe one, not the angry dictator; more below), michael Burnham spends viel of Discovery’s zuerst season trying to figure out what’s up with her new captain, a einer fond of fortune cookies and averse zu bright lights und chairs. Pro: Lorca took a chance on herstellung when nobody else would. Con: He deshalb seems kind of evil. The likelihood next — and it’s at some point revealed that, spoiler ahead, that made his way to ns prime world from the mirror universe after somehow taking ns original Lorca’s location — he commanded die Discovery through curiosity, a certain hand, and bei apparent sense von fairness. Shame about all the murder und scheming.

Key job moment: The season one illustration “Into ns Forest i Go” catches every side von Captain Lorca together he bravely goes into battle against Klingons, questionably decides kommen sie risk ns health of a crew member (and with him, die whole crew) kommen sie win the battle, then takes everyone into the mirror universe zu further his scheme des galactic conquest. It’s rather a journey, und one the reveals his true me at die end.

Would he be a an excellent boss? No, yet serving under Lorca would never ever be boring.

9. Captain Christopher Pike (Jeffrey Hunter)

seen in: Star Trek: the Original Series


*

Managerial style: Glum as hell. Part behind-the-scenes info: Jeffrey Hunter’s Captain Pike was supposed to be ns protagonist des the initial Star Trek series. NBC passed, but gave Gene Roddenberry ns unusual opportunity to make a 2nd pilot, this one featuring the now-familiar classic series cast (with only Leonard Nimoy’s Mr. Spock difficult around). Yet Roddenberry no done through Pike or ns original pilot. That became main to ns two-part episode “The Menagerie,” i m sorry recounts Pike und the Enterprise’s adventures ~ above Talos IV, residence to die Talosians and their reality-bending psychic powers. Hunter’s a fine actor, however it’s not hard to lakers why NBC was reluctant zu green-light a collection focusing ~ above Pike, who’s presented complaining about the burden of command. “You bet ns tired,” the tells the ship’s doctor. “Tired of being responsible for 203 lives. Tired von deciding which pflicht is too risky und which isn’t and who’s walk on the landing party und who doesn’t. And who lives … and who dies.” He sounds ready zu boldly curl up in a fetal position.

Key career moment: The signature momente for this incarnation des Pike comes hinweisen the end of ns episode when, having been burned and disfigured past recognition, he’s allowed to return kommen sie Talos IV und live out his days in the unreal paradise the rejected year before, even though he already seemed pretty much over truth as we understand it from the start.

Would he it is in a good boss? Spock and the rather seem zu respect him, deshalb perhaps his doubts don’t interfere v his ability to command, also if functioning under him seems prefer it would make zum a quite weary trudge through the cosmos.

8. Captain jonathan Archer (Scott Bakula)

watched in: Star Trek: Enterprise


*

Managerial style: Archer’s chill, which ist both his biggest strength together a leader and occasionally his greatest weakness. A former Boy Scout, lifelong water-polo enthusiast, und caring dog owner, Archer occasionally seems like he’s happy enough kommen sie be exploring the stern but could be even happier if that was nur hanging out and shooting the breeze v some pals. This can be an ext impression 보다 reality; Star Trek lore has him going on kommen sie become a decorated admiral und to be concerned as one von the greatest explorers an the at an early stage days des Starfleet und he definitely does a lot of exploring during ns show’s four-season run. But Scott Bakula rarely plays him as a man who has actually greatness bei his future. Archer usually seems a little annoyed that ns Enterprise’s adventures schutz cut right into his downtime. He’s not as melancholy together Jeffrey Hunter’s Captain Pike, but he sometimes seems nur as confirm out. Nonetheless, he was always good in a crisis, and could be a surprisingly shrewd diplomatic. It nur always seemed to take a major event to stir his interest.

Key job moment: In ns second-season illustration “A Night in Sickbay,” Archer hangs out with his sick dog Porthos wie man he should be tending kommen sie his diplomatic duties. It borders on dereliction of duty, even if it ist pretty endearing. It’s also a pretty great encapsulation des how Archer’s mental works.

Would he be a good boss? Sure. Probably. Why not? the be it s okay enough.

7. Captain james T. Kirk (Chris Pine)

checked out in: Star Trek, Star Trek into Darkness, Star Trek Beyond


*

Managerial style: If freundin like predictability, order, rules, regulations, und military precision, the belastung place you will do want kommen sie be zu sein the Kelvin cosmos Enterprise under die command of james T. Kirk. Chris Pine’s just-getting-started Kirk is young, impetuous, und brilliant — but mostly young and impetuous. It’s smart work, playing like ns Kirk we know from ns original Star Trek run before any des the turbulent edges had gotten sanded off. Pine’s Kirk zu sein a lot of fun kommen sie watch, yet it also seems prefer serving under ihm would be terrifying most von the time.

Key job moment: Forced kommen sie choose between rescuing in alien race und violating ns Prime Directive in the opened scenes des Star Trek into Darkness, Kirk barely seems zu consider the a choice at all. It’s nur the zuerst of many times he breaks the rules over the kurse of the film (plus the predecessor and successor). Sure, the all works out (even if Kirk does briefly wind up tot later in the movie), however it could schutz gone horribly wrong. This Kirk commands from die gut, sometimes while listening zu Beastie Boys. He is cool und fun, but…

Would he it is in a good boss? … Do sie really want zu work weil das a Starfleet captain finest described together “cool” and “fun” while exploring the furthest reaches of a danger universe?

6. Captain james T. Kirk (William Shatner)

seen in: Star Trek: ns Original Series, Star Trek: ns Motion Picture, stern Trek: Generations


Managerial style: You’re probably much better off working zum the slightly older Kirk played by William Shatner bei Original Series and its accompanying film series. (Okay, he is significantly older in the film series.) This Kirk there is no lost die spirit evident bei the younger Kirk, just it’s now tempered — punkt least a little bit — by experience. Working zum this Kirk isn’t without dangers des its own, an especially if you wearing a red uniform. He’s perfectly willing to send in away mannschaft into danger. Just as often, however, he’s ns one leading the team, and it’s hard zu underestimate ns esprit de corps created von a leader willing kommen sie put himself in harm’s way pflicht after mission. Prepare to work hard, and maybe die, but feel prefer you’re part des a mission that might change ns universe for the better.

Key career moment: Prepare so to aufführen to speeches. Kirk ist a einer of action and a man of romance, but above all, he is a man of ideals who willing zu go kommen sie great lengths zu protect those ideals. However first, he’ll try to persuade his opponents with words. In “The Omega Glory,” weil das instance, Shatner’s Kirk lectures ns primitive residents des a world whose advance paralleled earth until it took a wrong turn on ns glories des the U.S. Constitution, and he does that one emphatic syllable punkt a time: “We. The People …” Etc.

Mehr sehen: Die Unglaubliche Bilder Der Natur Und Fotokunst, 700+ Kostenlose Unglaubliche Und Ansicht

Would he be a an excellent boss? Chances room you’d liebe working zum Kirk up kommen sie the augenblicke he gott you killed.

5. Captain Philippa Georgiou, früh Universe (Michelle Yeoh)

watched in: Star Trek: Discovery


Managerial style: Collegial but firm, ns prime world Georgiou could rank even greater on this list if we had a huge sample von what she was like as a captain. In the early episodes von Discovery she appears to be competent, respected, fast on produziert feet and close to her crew, especially michael Burnham.

Key job moment: But notfall apparently close enough to stop Burnham from committing a mutinous act the she deems necessary zu prevent a war with the Klingons. Whether this ist a fail on Georgiou’s part — a missed chance to take a an essential suggestion native a subordinate — or overzealousness ~ above Burnham’s continues to be a question left open by Georgiou’s subsequent death.

Would she it is in a an excellent boss? It seems choose she would, particularly since herstellung death continues kommen sie haunt Burnham throughout the series. On die other hand, maybe listen to your trusted shipmate wie she states she to know what she’s talk about?

4. Captain benjamin Sisko (Avery Brooks)

watched in: Star Trek: Deep an are Nine


Managerial style: Firm, fair, und perpetually distracted. Melted out ~ above Starfleet life after losing his wife an the Battle von Wolf 359, Sisko only reluctantly bring away command of Deep space Nine, a space station situated close zu a galactic warm spot close to a wormhole and, till shortly prior to he presume command, ruled von the Cardassians. But Sisko quickly finds himself attracted into the leadership von the station und the politics des the bereich when die spiritual leader of nearby Bajor names him the Emissary von the Prophets. It’s every a gewächs to balance, also before new adversaries anfang to show up from die Gamma Quadrant — und on top of it all, Sisko has kommen sie serve as a single father kommen sie a teenage son. Possibly that’s why he sometimes seems dafür overworked. He’s a fine, inspiring leader, yet he so has a lot top top his plate, to run a space station while so acting as the first line von defense versus enemies known and unknown — und maybe serving together messiah zu a entirety race of people. Many Deep space Nine geschichten require Sisko to be reactive quite than proactive, whether managing a tavern keeper running a schwarz market under his sleep or the outbreak of a full-scale war. Strong and competent, Sisko could handle anything, but die series made ihm handle bei awful lot.

Key career moment: Deep space Nine presented shades of ethikrat grayness kommen sie Star Trek only suggested von its predecessors, never an ext than in the course of die protracted Dominion war arc, a danger conflict an which Sisko occasionally had kommen sie cheat and bend the truth zum the better good. Brooks’s performance always suggested the Sisko go a last of soul-searching prior to making any decision, however once made he never looked back, the unterschrift of a solid leader if ever before there was one.

Would he be a great boss? Chances room that, personal from die occasional curt acknowledgment, sie might only talk to er once or twice as he relocated from one crisis kommen sie another. Still, you’d end up respecting the mach das licht an out von Sisko.

3. Captain Christopher Pike (Anson Mount)

seen in: Star Trek: Discovery


Managerial style: In sharp contrast to Hunter’s Pike, Anson mount plays Christopher Pike as a einer who’s just happy to it is in out among the stars with shipmates he considers to be an ext like friends than co-workers. Discovery’s Pike is reminiscent des a cool camp counselor who nur wants everyone to oase a good time — deshalb long together they follow the rules and listen to his orders. In moments von crisis, Pike come off together unshaken yet commanding, and willing to use force versus his enemies wie necessary. He’s easygoing until situations force ihm to be otherwise. Climate he’s not.

Key career moment: Much des Discovery’s second season has actually involved the mystery von the Red Angel, in advanced being of unknown origin who’s driven von opaque motives und keeps making unexplained appearances hinweisen dramatic moments. It’s the sort von puzzle that would certainly rattle a lesser captain. However Pike has actually treated it together a finding out experience und kept bei open mind. In the season’s dritter episode, “New Eden,” he (mostly) adheres to die Prime Directive after ~ encountering a gruppe of transplanted humans who’ve synthesized earth faiths into a new religion, in which the Red stange plays a main role. Pike’s family background includes both scientific research and religion, und he advises a hands-off approach, because why obtain all worked hoch if sie don’t have to?

Would he be a good boss? Working for Pike seems favor a dream, honestly. That seems prefer the kind of ceo who’d teach you new skills, and then imply unwinding with a game von Ping-Pong the he wouldn’t shot all that hard zu win (though he entirely could if he want to).

2. Captain Jean-Luc Picard (Patrick Stewart)

seen in: Star Trek: die Next Generation, star Trek: Generations, stern Trek: Nemesis


Managerial style: Picard manages favor a benevolent however firm god. Speak in in authoritative voice (the accent helps), his every directive sounds together if handed under from above. However there’s a difference between having die trappings des authority and having ns record to rückseitig it up, und from his zuerst outing on the Enterprise — in which ns decision kommen sie separate the starship’s saucer section showed just how many lives were depending on er making die right selections — he renders it clear exactly how seriously he take it his job und how seriously he expects others kommen sie take theirs.

Key job moment: In part respects, ns definitive Picard momente can be found bei Star Trek: die Next Generation’s last episode, “All Good things …” in which Picard, weil das the zuerst time, joined his unterschied staff weil das their consistent poker game, with bei expression of regret that he’d never gained around to it before. Except an rare moments, Picard always holds himself punkt a distance as captain, also if Stewart’s performance always emphasizes the complex, passionate person beneath ns commanding exterior. He remains remote über design and it worked, however that an option isn’t without consequences.

Would he it is in a great boss? Picard would be in awe-inspiring boss an every sense. You’d find out a gewächs working v him, also if sie never feel like freundin truly knew him.

1. Captain Kathryn Janeway (Kate Mulgrew)

watched in: Star Trek: Voyager


Managerial style: Democratic, weist least up zu a point. Forced zu navigate in unexplored quadrant von the galaxy if commanding a crew made up von enemies forced kommen sie work with each other in bei attempt zu find their means home, Janeway has the highest level des difficulty von any des the captains ~ above this list. She rises to ns occasion über hearing the end all points des view, reconciling opposing stances wie man possible, working towards compromise, then eventually making an informed decision after listening to herstellung crew. Grounding in in impossible situation, she continues to be coolheaded and thoughtful no matte how trying ns circumstances become.

Key career moment: The biggest an obstacle faced von Janeway und the Voyager crew come not in the form of enemy races or dwindling offers — despite those don’t aid — however from die many moments that invite them zu abandon their principles. In the 2nd season’s “Alliances,” Janeway seeks a way zu sidestep dispute with ns Kazon (sort von the Gamma Quadrant’s dollar-store version of the Klingons). She considers first in alliance v a Kazon faction, then teaming nach oben with die Trabe, a seemingly much more civilized race. Then, despite ns wishes von a faction of her officers, she ultimately rejects both choices when she learns the Kazon can not be trusted und that die Trabe are just as bad an their very own way. It can mean acquisition longer kommen sie get zurück home, or perhaps never getting home punkt all, however she remains identified that produziert crew cave on kommen sie their best selves no matt what.

Would she be a an excellent boss? Yes. Janeway would certainly be die sort von boss sie might oase to complain about behind produziert back, yet she’s also the sort des boss you’d ende up specify name your zuerst child after.

Mehr sehen: Er Lief An Meiner Tochter (8) Vorbei: Der Wolf In Der Stadt, Ein Wolf In Der Stadt

Related


Every Star Trek Captain, Ranked von Competency jene you buy v our linke seite may earn New York a commission.